These resources are brought to you by the Cooperative Extension System and your Local Institution

FAQ #37524

Have a question? Try asking one of our Experts

I am considering going organic in my garden. A friend told me that botanical insecticides are all natural products toxic to pests but harmless to humans and other living things. Is that true?

Related resource areas: Gardens, Lawns & Landscapes


View as web page

Nothing could be further from the truth. Plant-derived poisons are only sometimes less toxic to man than synthetic pesticides. Rotenone, from the roots of derris plants, is toxic if swallowed or inhaled. Both pyrethrum and rotenone are low in toxicity to mammals yet highly toxic to fish. The yardstick for comparing acute, short-term toxicity is the LD50 or lethal dosage needed to kill fifty percent of a group of test animals (rats, rabbits, etc.). When you compare LD50 figures, the chemical insecticides Malathion and Sevin rank safer than nicotine sulfate, a botanical poison derived from tobacco.

No matter whether the chemical comes from a laboratory or a plant, it pays to be careful and read the label thoroughly.

Browse related FAQs by tag: horticulture, organic gardening, garden myth, botanical insecticides, garden fact or fiction

Have a specific question? Try asking one of our Experts

Unlike most other resources on the web, we have experts from Universities around the country ready to answer your questions.