Case Study 1 - When is it too soon to honor a living will? When does your health-care agent have the authority to make your medical decisions?
Grandpa Dan is 78 years old and, as far as he knows, is in good health except for some arthritis in his hands. Grandpa Dan has a living will. He has stated to his family many times that he does not want to be kept alive on life-support systems when it's his time to go. At his death, his only child, Joe, will inherit a large amount of property.
Joe is home for a weeklong visit with his wife, Sarah, and their three children. Grandpa Dan is thrilled to see his son, his daughter-in-law, and grandchildren, and he has gone out of his way to show the grandkids a great time. On the third morning of the visit, Grandpa Dan experiences severe chest pain that radiates down his left arm. Joe fears that his dad is having a heart attack. As he rushes to call 911, Sarah reminds him that his father has a living will and would not want an ambulance called.
Grandpa Dan also named Joe as his health-care agent in his health-care durable power of attorney. When Joe insists on calling 911, Sarah reminds him that he has the right to make this decision for his father and that he is morally obligated to honor his father's wishes.
Answers for Idaho Residents
The following answers are based upon Idaho law as of September 2004. The laws in other states may be different. Laws are subject to change, so please ask your attorney for answers to specific questions.
1. As health-care agent, Joe has the right to make this decision for his father at this time.
- Idaho answer: False
- As Grandpa Dan’s health-care agent, Joe has the right to make health-care decisions on his father’s behalf if Grandpa Dan’s is not able to make, understand, or communicate his health-care decisions. Is there any reason to believe that Grandpa Dan is incapable of making his own health-care decisions at this point?
2. Joe should honor his father’s living will and not call 911.
- Idaho answer: False
- The living will does not necessarily mean that someone wants to die at the first natural opportunity. Although Grandpa Dan could die from a heart attack, he could very well survive to live a productive and normal life. A living will is honored when the patient is either terminally and incurably ill or diagnosed in a persistent vegetative state. Grandpa Dan is not necessarily suffering from an incurable illness. Joe has no authority and no right to make this decision at this time.
Assume that Joe calls 911 and Emergency Medical Services arrives.
3. EMS will need a copy of Grandpa Dan’s living will.
- Idaho answer: False
- EMS has a duty to resuscitate the patient when they are called. Unless Grandpa Dan’s doctor has entered a “Do Not Resuscitate” (DNR) order for Grandpa Dan, EMS will resuscitate him. Although it isn’t wrong to give them a copy of Grandpa Dan’s living will, it is not necessary to do so.
4. Sarah will be able to stop EMS from resuscitating Grandpa Dan by showing them his living will.
- Idaho answer: False
- Unless Grandpa Dan’s doctor has entered a DNR order for Grandpa Dan, EMS must resuscitate him, regardless of what is written in his living will. Under Idaho law, the attending doctor must diagnose the patient as terminally ill. EMS personnel do not have the right to make this determination. Idaho law is written to protect patients from premature decisions made by people who are not qualified to make the decision.
5. After EMS takes Grandpa Dan to the hospital, Joe should show his doctors the health-care power of attorney and the living will.
- Idaho answer: True
- Although a copy of Grandpa Dan’s living will and health-care power of attorney should be in his medical file (assuming that he gave copies to his doctor), it is helpful if Joe can provide copies to the doctors who are taking care of Grandpa Dan.
- As health-care agent, Joe should have a copy of both documents in his files, or at least know where he can get a copy. He should also know where Grandpa Dan keeps the original of both documents, just in case he has to produce the originals for the doctors. Grandpa Dan should have discussed his wishes with Joe and made sure that his son is prepared to represent his interests with the doctors and hospitals.
6. Once the doctors have a copy of Grandpa Dan’s health-care power of attorney, they must consult with Joe before making major health-care decisions.
- Idaho answer: It depends
- It depends upon whether Grandpa Dan is able to communicate his health-care decisions rationally. As long as Grandpa Dan is competent and able to make and communicate his health-care decisions, the doctors must consult Grandpa Dan. Joe has no authority as health-care agent until Grandpa Dan is unable to communicate his health-care decisions rationally.
7. Joe, as Grandpa Dan’s health-care agent, can revoke Grandpa Dan’s living will.
- Idaho answer: False
- Under Idaho law, only Grandpa Dan can revoke the living will.
Return to Advance Directives Case Study 1.
See all Advance Directives Case Studies.
Return to the Communicate Your Advance Directives for Health Care learning lesson.
Credits
Adapted for use in the Legally Secure Your Financial Future: Organize, Communicate, Prepare program.
Content development by:
Beverly Healy, M.Ed., Professor and Ada County Extension Educator,
University of Idaho
Reviewed for Idaho use by:
Robert Aldridge, attorney, Boise, Idaho (September 2004)
Robert Wreggelsworth, attorney, Boise, Idaho (June 2005)
This information is provided as a public service and is designed to acquaint you with certain legal issues and concerns. It is not intended to be a substitute for legal advice, nor does it tell you everything you may need to know about this subject. Future changes in the law cannot be predicted, and statements in these materials are based solely on the laws in force on the date of release noted on this page.
This document is for non-profit educational purposes only. This document may not be used by a profit-making company or organization. When used by a non-profit organization, appropriate credit must be given to the Cooperative Extension Legally Secure Your Financial Future: Organize, Communicate, Prepare education program. Materials for this program were developed by a team from six land-grant universities. The program is included in the program toolkit of the Cooperative Extension Financial Security in Later Life national initiative. For more information go to: http://www.csrees.usda.gov/fsll.